Reviewer Selection Process and Guidelines

The Selection of Reviewers

Before a manuscript enters the Hall of Scholarship, it must be judged by the Guardians of Knowledge — scholars who possess:

• Mastery in their chosen realm

• Advanced academic runes (Ph.D. or equivalent)

• A history of victories in published quests

• Membership in respected academies

• A vow of neutrality and honesty

• Previous service as guardians

• Time to inspect the manuscript thoroughly

• Commitment to the ancient ethics of COPE

The Guardian’s Duties (Do’s)

• Protect the scrolls with utmost secrecy

• Offer fair and wise counsel

• Provide thorough insights into strengths and weaknesses

• Honor the sacred timeline

• Declare any ties or conflicts

• Judge the scroll, not its creator

• Use noble and respectful language

• Alert the council of any dark practices (plagiarism, deception)

The Forbidden Acts (Don’ts)

• Revealing sacred writings

• Speaking to the scroll’s author

• Delaying judgment for selfish reasons

• Stealing ideas from the scroll

• Showing favoritism or grudges

• Passing the duty to another without permission

• Focusing only on minor imperfections

• Using insulting or emotional speech

Honor

Guardians who perform exceptionally earn recognition in the annual Scroll of Honor.